Broken Arrow homes for sale in Newberry

  Currently Listed Sold (past year)
Total 2 3
Avg List Price $246,949 $248,000
Avg SOLD Price   $242,333
Avg Seller Discount   2.2%
More neighborhood stats here!

2 current homes for sale in Broken Arrow

545 SW 257TH TERRACE Newberry, FL 32669
$249,899 - 3 BR, 1.1 BA
RE/MAX PROFESSIONALS - MLS # 536716 -
405 SW 257TH TERRACE Newberry, FL 32669
$244,000 - 3 BR, 2 BA
RABELL REALTY GROUP LLC - MLS # 713383 -


Data updated on March 9, 2026. Copyright 2026 Gainesville Multiple Listing, Inc. All rights reserved.